Tag Archives: paravrtti

The Turning-About

The unitive path has now reached a decisive threshold. Recollection has gathered the Bodhi-Mind from its habitual dispersion, simple regard has weakened the sovereignty of discursive consciousness, and the Quiet of the Unborn has exposed the limitation inherent in every contemplative state, however subtle or sublime. The practitioner has learned that tranquility is not the Unborn, that interior spaciousness is not the Unborn, that luminous awareness is not the Unborn, and that even the most refined witnessing consciousness remains within the domain of the born. Yet this series of negations does not leave the contemplative standing before a metaphysical void. Rather, it prepares for the radical reversal that the Lankāvatāra Sūtra identifies as the turning-about, the parāvṛtti, at the deepest seat of consciousness. Until this turning occurs, the seeker may become extraordinarily refined, but the fundamental orientation of consciousness remains essentially unchanged. read more

Posted in Premium, Spirituality, The Dark Night of the Soul and Beyond | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Beyond the Ten Stages: Kūkai, the Lankāvatāra, and the Unborn

Kūkai’s celebrated Ten Stages of Mind (Jūjūshin) represents one of the most ambitious attempts in East Asian Buddhism to map the progressive transformation of human consciousness, beginning with a mind dominated by instinct and desire and ascending through increasingly refined ethical, philosophical, and Buddhist orientations until reaching the esoteric realization of Mahāvairocana characteristic of Shingon Buddhism. The architecture is impressive, encyclopedic, and at times almost overwhelming in its determination to locate the many possibilities of religious consciousness within a single ascending hierarchy. Yet when this elaborate structure is placed beside the Lankāvatāra Sūtra, Yogācāra’s analysis of consciousness, and the Mahāyāna doctrine of the ten bodhisattva bhūmis, an intriguing question arises: does awakening truly consist in climbing from one increasingly exalted state of mind to another, or must the very consciousness that constructs and experiences such stages eventually undergo a more radical transformation? The Lankāvatāra points toward parāvṛtti—the profound “turning-about” at the deepest seat of consciousness—where the discriminative machinery of vijñāna and its habitually projected world are seen through at their root. From the perspective of Unborn Mind Zen, this introduces an even sharper distinction. The Unborn cannot be situated at the summit of Kūkai’s hierarchy, nor can it be regarded as an eleventh stage beyond the tenth, for the Unborn is not a progressively acquired condition of consciousness at all. Likewise, the ten bhūmis need not be understood as ten degrees by which one gradually manufactures or approaches the Unborn; rather, they disclose the progressive maturation of the Bodhi-Child once the fundamental orientation toward awakening has occurred. Recognition is not gradual, though maturation is. Thus Kūkai’s Ten Stages, the Yogācārin transformation of consciousness, and the bodhisattva bhūmis can be read as three profoundly different maps of the spiritual journey—each illuminating something important, yet none capable of enclosing that which precedes every map. What follows, then, is not a dismissal of Kūkai’s magnificent spiritual architecture, but an attempt to look through it from the standpoint of the Lankāvatāra and the Unborn, asking what remains when the stages have fulfilled their purpose, the ladder has reached its limit, and finally even the ladder itself disappears. read more

Posted in Kūkai, Premium, Zen | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Karma’s Repository

The advent of Mahāyāna Buddhism that coincided with the beginning of the Christian-era gave birth to the most sublime innovations in Buddhist-thought that have not been surpassed even to this day. Colorful, dynamic and transcendent in scope, resplendent with rich metaphorical language founded in the rich soil of sūtra and śāstra laden literature, the Mahāyāna shaped a new and indefatigable-direction for the nature of the karma-effect. According to the Sarvāstivādin and Theravādin doctrine, one’s goal in unraveling the karmic-equation was to slowly and diligently eradicate it through determined demolition of its defilements, in essence, being empowered to save-oneself. In Mahāyāna doctrine the emphasis was not so much in eradicating its effects, but standing above and beyond it by not focusing so much on individual-salvation, but by the salvation of others by practicing the six perfections or pāramitās. This found its inestimable worth in the cult of the Bodhisattvas. Generally, the causes of birth for ordinary beings are past deeds (karman) and defilements (klesa). But the Bodhisattva’s birth is unique in that it is caused exclusively by his will and purpose. Thus, a Bodhisattva volunteers to be born (saṃcintyabhavopapatti—intentional birth) into a life of suffering for the precise purpose of alleviating the suffering of sentient beings. read more

Posted in Karma and Rebirth, Premium | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Conjoined Realities

To this very day there is little consensus as to the precise-relationship between tathagatā-garbha and alaya-vijñāna. Seong-Uk Kin, in his excellent extract, “Understanding Tsung-mi’s View on Buddha Nature”, nicely extrapolates on its evolving traits. The concept of alaya-vijñāna first appeared in the Samdhinirmocana-sūtra, circa early 4th century C.E. in India. This Sutra asserts that the alaya-vijñāna is a form of consciousness that exhibits particular modes of perception. It is here that it also takes on the familiar metaphorical-shape as a receptacle that house seeds of karma as well as the propensity for all future karma. It is essentially based on this understanding that Yogācāra Buddhists determine how all phenomenal-diversity develops; indeed, for them alaya-vijñāna is the hallmark for all conventional realities, and it is how subjective-agents interact in their environment. For Chinese Buddhists, their main concern was how tathagatāgarbha and alaya-vijñāna differed, especially pertaining as to whether alaya-vijñāna was pure or impure. The great Translator in China, Paramartha, asserted that it was defiled-garbha. As time progressed the Chinese developed their own unique Yogācāra schools that particularly focused on this concern. Fa-shang (495-580) represented one of these schools and expounded that tathagatāgarbha and alaya-vijñāna were exclusively separate from one another: alaya-vijñāna was totally impure and existed solely to house all karmic and phenomenal-based associations; whereas the tathagatāgarbha was solely “pure” and the ultimate source for all there is. This stood in stark contrast to other Yogācāra schools that asserted that alaya-vijñāna in-itself was pure and the sustainer of all phenomena—it was completely synonymous with the tathagatāgarbha . In a masterstroke of providing the middle-ground for all these opposing schools, the Awakening of Faith integrated both concepts: alaya-vijñāna was bifurcated as epistemologically a combination of both pure and impure aspects of consciousness, while ontologically it was not distinct from tathagatāgarbha. When in awakened-mode the alaya was pure; when in delusion, it was impure. The following diagram (from Seong-Uk Kin’s extract), depicts how the Awakening of Faith harmonized tathagatāgarbha and alaya-vijñāna as the “One Mind in Two Aspects”: read more

Posted in Premium, Tsung-mi: An Intimate Study | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Staying in the Mind Current

iii. 2. Dhyana

3.2 Uninterrupted Meditation

Dhyana is sustained Dhāranā. After mastering the ability to remain focused on one point without any interruption, one then develops the ability to enter into an uninterrupted current of focus. It is said that when one enters into Deep Dhyana then one is truly meditating. For instance, one sets aside a particular time frame for meditation, say One-Hour. At the end of the session it felt like you were only participating in this for just 5 minutes—it’s then that you know you’ve been truly meditating. If, on the other hand, the whole experience seems so laborious—unending—then you are certainly not in the “current”, but rather, fighting against it. read more

Posted in Premium, The Yogasūtras of Patañjali | Tagged , , , , , , | 8 Comments

Mind Stabilization

i.35-39 The Means to secure Absolute Contemplative Focus

Patañjali utilizes a word in this section that will sound familiar to Lankavatarian adepts: pravṛtti. Fernando Tola and Carmen Dragonetti (mentioned in earlier posts) translate it as follows: read more

Posted in Premium, The Yogasūtras of Patañjali | Tagged , , , , , | 5 Comments